Nornickel’s Polar Division, Norilsk, Russia

I. S. Kibroev, Hydrogeologists of Geophysical Service of Mine Shafts at Center for Geodynamic Safety, KibroevIS@nornik.ru
A. S. Manzhosov, Head of Geophysical Service of Mine Shafts at Center for Geodynamic Safety
A. A. Lukyanov, Geophysicist of Geophysical Service of Mine Shafts at Center for Geodynamic Safety
V. E. Popova, Chief Specialist of Hydrogeological Monitoring and Mining Supervision Department at Center for Geologic Work

Mine shafts are the critical underground structures and, technologically and functionally, play an important role in the mine hoisting system. Shutdown of vertical mine shafts because of their instability, unsafety and emergency condition restrains operation of the whole mine and deteriorates its economic performance. For this reason, assessment of shaft stability and its support integrity is crucial for the sustainable and trouble-free operation of mines, and for the health and lives of mine personnel. All phases, from sinking to operation of mine shafts, involve factors which have an adverse effect on shaft support and on adjacent rock mass. The influence factors have different nature depending on the shaft sinking technology, geological conditions, flowsheet of protective pillar extraction, dynamic loads, etc. In view of a variety of causes of mine shaft damages and since deformations develop in mine shafts as a consequence of integrated impact (and symptoms of damages may be similar in case of different causes), it is necessary to carry out a comprehensive analysis in order to successively and reasonably eliminate the secondary causes and to identify the dominant causes. This study presents the analytical results on the main causes of damages of support in vertical mine shafts as a case-study of mines in the Talnakh ore province in the Norilsk industrial region. The analysis of the causes of damages in the vertical mine shaft support used a bulk of actual data, including the evidence of other agencies and the experience of the Geophysical Service of Mine Shafts at the Center for Geodynamic Safety. On the basis of the integrated analysis, the key groups of factors that influence deformation processes in mine shafts were identified. The studies show that the highest impact on the stability of mine shafts in the Talnakh ore province is exerted by industrial factors, with the dominant role of stoping operations in protection pillars. This problem is particularly acute in case of highly valuable ore bodies, when it is economically beneficial to reach maximum extraction of mineral reserves.

1. Suraev V. A. Measures to extend life of support in vertical mine shafts in mines of the Norilsk industrial province. The Youth and Science: Proceedings of VII All-Russian Conference of Students, Post-Graduates and Young Scientists in Commemoration of the 50th Anniversary of the First Man-in-Space Flight. Krasnoyarsk : Sibirskiy federalnyi universitet, 2011.
2. Manets I. G., Snegirev Yu. D., Parshintsev V. P. Maintenance and Remount Service of Shafts. 2^nd revised and enlarged edition. Moscow : Nedra, 1987. 327 p.
3. Pleshko M. S., Pankratenko A. N., Pleshko M. V., Nasonov A. A. Assessment of stress–strain behavior of shaft lining in bottomhole area during sinking by realtime monitoring and computer modeling data. Eurasian Mining. 2021. No. 1. pp. 25–30.
4. Mashin A. N. Concept of integrated technical evaluation of mine shafts. MIAB. 2023. No. 10. pp. 31–42.
5. Chen C., Zhou J., Zhou T., Yong W. Evaluation of vertical shaft stability in underground mines: comparison of three weight methods with uncertainty theory. Natural Hazards. 2021. Vol. 109, Iss. 2. pp. 1457–1479.
6. Pankratenko A. N., Mashin A. N., Nasonov A. A., Parinov D. S. Features of structural assessment of long life mine shafts. Gornyi Zhurnal. 2023. No. 1. pp. 20–26.
7. Ma X., Wang Y., Lin T., Yang L. Intelligent decision system for vertical shaft blasting scheme based on knowledge base and its application. IEEE Access. 2021. Vol. 9. pp. 163831–163842.
8. Sun B., Yang X., Chu H., Chen F., Wang J. et al. Evolution law of surrounding rock stress field for ultra-deep shaft development blasting. Scientific Reports. 2025. Vol. 15. DOI: 10.1038/s41598–025–88722-w
9. Demin V. F., Demina T. V., Batanin F. K., Teterev N. A. Formation of progressive technological schemes for carrying out and supporting mine workings. Safety of Processes and Productions : IV International Conference Proceedings. Yekaterinburg : Izdatelstvo UGGU, 2022. pp. 5–10.
10. Kotikov D. A., Veselova A. V., Romanova E. L., Demenkov P. A. Analysis of the factors of loss of stability of vertical shaft lining during long-term operation in the Far North. MIAB. 2024. No. 11-1. pp. 57–80
11. Karasev M. A., Protosenya A. G., Katerov A. M., Petrushin V. V. Analysis of shaft lining stress state in anhydrite–rock salt transition zone. Rudarsko-geološkonaftni zbornik. 2022. Vol. 37, No. 1. pp. 151−162.
12. Borshchevsky S. V., Prokopov A. Yu., Formos V. F., Glebko V. V. On research primary cause of verrtical shafts of mines in Donbass. Izvestiya Donetskogo gornogo instituta. 2013. No. 1(32). pp. 47−52.
13. Tarasov V. V., Chaginov A. V. Stabilization of support at intersections of vertical shafts and horizontal openings in complicated mining-and-geological conditions of the Upper Kama deposit. MIAB. 2014. No. 4. pp. 81–85.
14. Tarasov V. V., Pestrikova V. S. Review of shaft excavation accidents at Upper Kama potash deposit. MIAB. 2015. No. 5. pp. 23–29.
15. Xia K., Chen C., Zheng Y., Zhang H., Liu X. et al. Engineering geolog y and ground collapse mechanism in the Chengchao Iron-ore Mine in China. Engineering Geology. 2019. Vol. 249. pp. 129–147.
16. Xia K., Chen C., Deng Y., Xiao G., Zheng Y. et al. In situ monitoring and analysis of the mining-induced deep ground movement in a metal mine. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences. 2018. Vol. 109. pp. 32–51.
17. Cheng G., Chen C., M a T., Liu H., Tang C. A case study on the strata movement mechanism and surface deformation regulation in Chengchao underground iron mine. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering. 2017. Vol. 50, Iss. 4. pp. 1011–1032.
18. Marysyuk V. P., Darbinyan T. P., Andreev A. A., Vilner M. A. Geomechanical characteristic of ventilation shaft VS-3 in Oktyabrsky mine during extraction of mineral reserves from protective pillar. Gornyi Zhurnal. 2021. No. 1. pp. 64–69.
19. Sun Q., Ma F., Guo J., Li G., Feng X. Deformation failure mechanism of deep vertical shaft in Jinchuan Mining Area. Sustainability. 2020. Vol. 12, Iss. 6. ID 2226.
20. Yao Z., Wang C., Xue W., Zhang P., Fang Y. Experimental study on the dynamic mechanical properties of high-performance hybrid fiber-reinforced concrete of mine shaft lining. Journal of Materials Research and Technology. 2021. Vol. 14, No. 5. pp. 888–900.